Top
×
J Unexplored Med Data 2017;2:102-4.10.20517/2572-8180.2017.11© The Author(s) 2017.
Open AccessEditorial

Relationship between physicians and nurses in China: collaboration or subordination?

See all authors and affiliations

1Department of Gastroenterology, Chongqing University Cancer Hospital & Chongqing Cancer Institute & Chongqing Cancer Hospital, Chongqing 400030, China.

2Editorial Office, TMR Integrative Nursing, TMR Publishing Group, Tianjin 300020, China.

3Department of Nursing, Chongqing University Cancer Hospital & Chongqing Cancer Institute & Chongqing Cancer Hospital, Chongqing 400030, China.

Correspondence Address: Dr. Yuan-Ping Pi, Department of Nursing, Chongqing University Cancer Hospital & Chongqing Cancer Institute & Chongqing Cancer Hospital, 181 Hanyu Road, Shapingba District, Chongqing 400030, China. E-mail: cqzlyyhlb@163.com ; Dr. Wei-Qing Chen, Department of Gastroenterology, Chongqing University Cancer Hospital & Chongqing Cancer Institute & Chongqing Cancer Hospital, 181 Hanyu Road, Shapingba District, Chongqing 400030, China. E-mail: chenwq20140809@163.com

    ...

    This is an open access article licensed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, as long as the original author is credited and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

    Introduction

    Following the international medical model, physicians and nurses are supposed to be individual element in healthcare system characterized by collaboration and cooperation, which are both aims at solving the disease, restoring and maintaining health, and achieving world health eventually[1]. That is to say, a rational relationship between physician and nurse should be constructed [Figure 1], which may be termed as eco-relationship of physician-nurse under normal value. Although enormous developments have been achieved in medicine[2], a terrible fact is still stinging the healthcare system in China. Nursing science has been licensed to be as first-class discipline which is the same with Clinical medicine[3]; however the relationship between physicians and nurses has been distorted. That is to say, nurses and corresponding work are subordinate to physicians, which directly and greatly obstacles the ecological development of nursing science in China. It is noted that the terrible physician-nurse relationship will cause several negative effects, such as imbalance assignment of medical sources and incomplete implementation of medical plans. As a result, it a presses need to research the reasons behind this deviant phenomenon, and then developing the substantive strategies to normalize the relationship between physicians and nurses in China.

    Figure 1. Eco-relationship of physician-nurse under normal value

    Reasons behind this phenomenon

    Imperfect policies

    Numerous laws and regulations have been issued in order to specify the work scope, position the role function, and protect the lawful right and interests of physicians. Unfortunately, these documents targeting nurses are still missing. This fact generated an awkward phenomenon that physicians play an important role in the healthcare system compared to nurses. And thus, nurses are supposed to be ordered by physicians.

    Haphazard training program of specialized nurses

    Several training programs have been designed for the purpose of strengthening construction on specialized nurses after drew on foreign experiences. However, the training period (e.g. 3 to 6 months) and contents (e.g. missing from evidence-based practice) of these programs were haphazard[4]. In contrast, those training programs targeting physicians was designed to have adequate training time and rational contents. This fact directly causes a result that “specialized nurses” are lack of ability to collaborating and cooperating with physicians to address actual problems.

    Subjective superiority of physicians

    Some physicians in China were not reluctant to change the inherent superiority of dominating medical practice although the relationship between physicians and nurses has changed from subordination-execution style to collaboration-cooperation style[5]. This causes a result that doctor and nurse cooperation are just a daydream.

    Subjective inferiority of nurses

    Traditionally, nurses only play a follower of physician in medical practice. And thus, most of them are still difficult to change the traditional inferiority of acting as assistant of physicians although nursing science has been licensed as first-class discipline.

    Deflected social orientation

    According to the traditional thinking, only the physicians were seen to be as the normal healthcare practitioners in the public; however nurse just was treated as manual worker who is familiar with the nanny. This phenomenon also drives the subjective superiority of physicians and strengthens the subjective inferiority of nurses.

    Coping strategies

    Improving policies

    The all-level government and system should actively improve associated laws and regulations (e.g. Nursing Law) with nurses in China so that the unique role of nurse practitioners in medical practice can be emphasized and specified.

    Promoting the education level of the nurses

    The fact of low education level of most of the nurses strengths the fixed thinking of many physicians that nurses only assist physicians to deal with almost all medical questions because most of the physicians have obtained a doctor degree; however majority of nurses only took an associate degree. As a result, it is important in order to promote the education level of the nurses.

    Expanding the role functions and works scope

    Traditionally, nurses just passively perform the physicians’ orders in China. However, nurses in Western countries not only help physicians to carry out practice tasks, but also prescribe nursing order for patients and give government officials some suggestions for reforming system. And thus, role functions and work scope of domestic nurses must be expanded.

    Positive social propaganda

    Deflected social orientation is a critical contributor to distort relationship between physicians and nurses in China. In order to normalize this distorted relationship, it is inevitable that social media, all-level government, healthcare system, education organizations, professional societies, and individual nurse should make a positive social propaganda.

    Reforming the practice model

    In China, all tasks in a clinical department including medical treatment-related and nursing care-related things were dominated by chief, however head nurse just play a second-stage governor. In fact, however, each discipline has unique characteristics which are different from others and thus chief and head nurse should dominate medical treatment-related and nursing care-related things respectively and these two roles are all first-stage governor in a clinical department.

    Drawing on foreign advanced experiences

    Although significant developments of domestic medicine have been achieved within the last dozen years, however modern medicine (especially nursing science) is still a system dominated by Western countries such as America. Consequently, China should draw on foreign advanced experiences to better domestic healthcare practice and system.

    Declarations

    Authors’ contributions

    Conceived this editorial: X. Tian, Y.P. Pi, W.Q. Chen

    Searched and sorted information: X. Tian, X.L. Liu

    Drafted the manuscript: X. Tian

    Critically reviewed the whole manuscript: Y.P. Pi, W.Q. Chen

    Approved the authorships and submission: X. Tian, X.L. Liu, Y.P. Pi, W.Q. Chen

    Financial support and sponsorship

    None.

    Conflicts of interest

    There are no conflicts of interest.

    Patient consent

    Not applicable.

    Ethics approval

    Not applicable.

    Copyright

    © The Author(s) 2017.

    References

    • 1. Hojat M, Nasca TJ, Cohen MJ, Fields SK, Rattner SL, Griffiths M, Ibarra D, de Gonzalez AA, Torres-Ruiz A, Ibarra G, Garcia A. Attitudes toward physician-nurse collaboration: a cross-cultural study of male and female physicians and nurses in the United States and Mexico. Nurs Res 2001;50:123-8.

      DOIPubMed
    • 2. Zhang SL. The statistical analysis of outpatients and academic impact about scientific papers in China based on ESI and InCites databases. Henan: Xinxiang Medical University; 2015.

    • 3. Zhang YQ. Exploration of development of nursing discipline. J Shanghai Jiaotong University (Med Sci) 2011;31:693-5.

    • 4. Tian X, Ma L, Yi LJ, Lian JX, Wang Y, Cao H, Song GM. Research status and competence of clinical nursing specialist and construction on core competence model for osteoporosis specialized nurse in Mainland China. Int J Caring Sci 2015;8:152-63.

    • 5. Yang XL, Lv HY, Li SG. Comparative study on attitudes of physician and nurse toward physician-nurse collaboration. Chin J Nurs 2006;41:5466-9.

    Article Access Statistics

    • Viewed: 1444
    • Downloaded: 116
    • Cited: Crossref0

    Table of Contents